Pros and Cons of Counter Finishes

Hello my design friends! I hope your week is going well and you have a design and decor project or two planned :) A number of you have recently asked about the type of counter material you should select whether it’s for your kitchen or your bathroom. There is a wide selection of counter top materials available which can cause confusion and be overwhelming. The decision really depends on who will use the space, how often, your habits and of course your budget. It also depends on the style or look you have in your home or that you want to achieve.

To assist you in your decision making process and/or support future reno decisions, I have summarized the pros and cons of each of the materials currently available.

Granite

Pros

  • wide range of colours (blues, browns, reds, mottled whites, black

  • minimal to no visible seams

  • durable surface

  • heat resistant

Cons

  • expensive

  • porous so has to be sealed to resist stains

  • chips and pits

Blue Granite Countertop.jpg

Marble

Pros

  • outstanding work surface for baking or making fresh pasta

  • durable

  • striking patterns

Cons

  • high maintenance

  • requires repeated sealing

  • expensive

  • fewer colours and patterns that granite

  • softer so may show knife scars

Marble Counter.jpg

Soapstone and Slate

Pros

  • non-porous so bacteria resistant

  • doesn’t require sealing

Cons

  • both materials come in fewer colours than other materials

  • soapstone is soft so may show knife marks

  • doesn’t require sealing

  • slate is brittle particularly at corners so can chip/crack/break

  • expensive

Photo below left (soapstone): Great Mountain Soapstone, photo below right (slate): Prairat Fhunah

Quartz

Pros

  • doesn’t require sealing

  • broad range of colours and patterns

  • non-porous so bacteria resistant

  • durable

  • low maintenance

Cons

  • expensive

Common quartz brand names include: Zodiaq, Silestone, Cambria, and Caesarstone.

Photo: Andre Francois MacKenzie

Photo: Andre Francois MacKenzie

Solid Surface

This material is manufactured from dense acrylic, polyester or a blend of the two. The seams are fused to make undetectable joints, which works well if you require a large counter or a long section of counter top. And solid-surface sinks are available to match the counters too!

Pros

  • low maintenance

  • wide variety of colour and pattern choices available

  • non-porous

  • repairable

Cons

  • not heat-resistant

  • will show scratches

Common solid surface brand names include Corian, Gibraltar, and Avonite. There is also a new, eco-friendly option called Paperstone which is manufactured from from recycled paper and non-petroleum resins.

Corian Counter.jpg

Concrete

Concrete has been a popular choice over the past 5 years.

Pros

  • extremely hard and durable

  • makes a great work surface

  • wide range of colors, and artistic treatments can be added such as glass, stones, etc.

  • won’t scratch

  • heat-resistant

Cons

  • expensive

  • needs sealing

Concrete - Misku.jpg

Plastic Laminate

Pros

  • affordable

  • lots of colours

  • comes in ready to install slabs

Cons

  • can chip or scratch

  • not heat-resistant

Most commonly known under the brand name Formica.

Photo: The Country Handyman

Photo: The Country Handyman

Wood

Pros

  • warm

  • ideal work surface

  • bacteria resistant

  • heat resistant

Cons

  • medium maintenance

  • will show knife marks

Photo: Spencer Pugh

Photo: Spencer Pugh

Ceramic Tile

Pros

  • affordable

  • lots of colour & style choices

  • ceramic tile is non-porous

Cons

  • grout traps crumbs and dirt

  • regular grout resealing needed

Ceramic Tile Counter - Rona.jpg

I hope this summary of counter top option pros and cons will help you in the planning of your projects. If you have questions about the best counter for your reno be sure to reach out! I love to hear what you are working on and what interior design and decor challenges you are facing that I can provide guidance on.

For more design and decor inspiration, like and follow Simply Swank Decor on:

Facebook (https://www.faebook.com/simplyswankhomedecor/)

Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/simplyswankdecor/)

Pinterest (https://www.pinterest.ca/simplyswankdeco/)